Old Fashioned Apple Pie

12 INGREDIENTS • 20 STEPS • 3HRS 30MINS

Old Fashioned Apple Pie

A cozy Eggland's Best apple pie made for sharing, with tender Granny Smith apples, warm cinnamon, and a golden homemade crust.
Love This Recipe?
A cozy Eggland's Best apple pie made for sharing, with tender Granny Smith apples, warm cinnamon, and a golden homemade crust.
author_avatar
Eggland's Best
ONLY EGGLAND’S BEST hens are fed our proprietary all-vegetarian feed—that’s what makes our eggs more nutritious.

3HRS 30MINS

Total Time

Ingredients

Servings
8
us / metric
All-Purpose Flour
4 cups
All-Purpose Flour
not sifted
All-Purpose Flour
2 Tbsp
All-Purpose Flour
not sifted
Salt
1 pinch
Salt
Granulated Sugar
1 cup
Granulated Sugar
Granulated Sugar
2 Tbsp
Granulated Sugar
Vegetable Shortening
2 cups
Vegetable Shortening
Egg
2
Eggs
yolks only
Orange Juice
6 fl oz
Orange Juice
up to 8 fl oz
Granny Smith Apple
10
Granny Smith Apples
up to 12
Ground Cinnamon
1 tsp
Ground Cinnamon
Butter
as needed
Butter
I use 3-4 squares
Large Egg White
4 Tbsp
Large Egg Whites
Love This Recipe?
author_avatar
Eggland's Best
ONLY EGGLAND’S BEST hens are fed our proprietary all-vegetarian feed—that’s what makes our eggs more nutritious.

Cooking Instructions

Hide images
step 1
Peel and slice Granny Smith Apples (10).
step 2
Combine All-Purpose Flour (4 cups), Salt (1 pinch) and Granulated Sugar (2 Tbsp).
step 3
Add in Vegetable Shortening (2 cups) and combine (mixtures should be lumpy, with pea sized pieces).
step 4
Make a well in the middle and place the yolks from Eggs (2).
step 5
Add Orange Juice (6 fl oz).
step 6
Gently fold flour/shortening mixture into egg and then combine thoroughly without over handling.
step 7
Form combined dough into a ball & cover with wax/parchment paper. Refrigerate overnight.
step 8
In a large bowl, combine apples with All-Purpose Flour (2 Tbsp), Ground Cinnamon (1 tsp) and Granulated Sugar (1 cup). Mix until apples are thoroughly coated.
step 9
Cut chilled dough into four even sections.
step 10
On a dry, floured surface, roll out one section of dough starting from the middle and rolling out. If dough begins to stick, dust with flour. Try to keep dough thickness consistent without letting any section get too thin.
step 11
Lift dough and transfer to your round pie dish. (You can use a rolling pin to help with the transport).
step 12
Cover the bottom of the dish with the crust, trimming extra and patching any holes that might have formed.
step 13
Place all apples in the pie dish.
step 14
Place 3-4 squares of Butter (as needed) on top of apples.
step 15
Repeat dough rolling and place second piece on top of apples.
step 16
Trim extra dough from the edges, fold up and pinch closed. (Be careful not to have too much dough around your edge or it won't cook thoroughly.)
step 17
Poke a couple fork holes in the top, then brush the top of the pie with Large Egg Whites (4 Tbsp) (be careful not to let the liquid pool in the edges).
step 18
Place pie dish on a pan or cookie sheet and cook on 450 for 10-15 min (until pretty brown).
step 19
Turn down over to 350 and cook for 50-60 min.
step 20
Remove pie dish from pan and place on a cooling rack until thoroughly cooled.
step 20 Remove pie dish from pan and place on a cooling rack until thoroughly cooled.

Tags

Shellfish-Free
Vegetarian
Game Day
top